My intended focus of the thread was not depth, nor a referendum on judging. Yeah, I mentioned depth in the original post and made the point that a close stance can make it harder to hit depth, but yeah, I'm only really interested in bar position and how low is too low and does it matter if you can stand upright with the weight. I don't know what level the girl in the OP competes in.
Again, this is the internet. Don't take it personally. I don't remember accusing anyone of anything other than having a terrible looking squat but I'll reread what I've written.